Intellectual Foundations of Ontologies in Willard Van Orman Quine Philosophy

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

• Mahdi Shaghaghi
• GolamReza Fadaie

University of Tehran

10.22067/riis.v5i1.25115

Abstract

Purpose: The aim of this study was to study the theoretical refinement of ontologies as a retrieval tool to examine their intellectual foundations. To this end, firstly the definitions of ontologies were extracted and their intellectual origins were discussed. Secondly, the intellectual foundations of ontologies in the technical qualities of ontologies were investigated. Then, these foundations were sought in the Quine philosophy.
Methodology: The documentary research method was used for the disquisition of intellectual foundations for the definitions and technical qualities of ontologies. Conceptual analysis was used as an approach for identifying these foundations in Quine philosophy.
Findings: This study showed that one of the most important foundations of ontologies is “Ontological Commitment” that was first introduced in Quine philosophy. Ontologies have commitments only to the entities that could be represented. Thus, being or not being of entities in ontologies is contingent to the capability of representation and not to their real existence in the world. Likewise, we found that with regard to Quine philosophy and its infiltration in theoretical and technical foundations of ontologies, relations to this tool are extensional but not intentional like relations in thesauruses or classification schemes

Keywords

• Willard Van Orman Quine
• Ontologies
• Ontology construction
• Ontological commitment
• Inadequacy of reference
• Inadequacy of intension

---

References

Alston, William P. (1958). Ontological Commitments. Philosophical Studies, 9, 8-15. Retrieved 5, April, 2013, form: http://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/handle/2027.42/43413/11098_2004_Article_BF00797866.pdf?sequence=1

Amann, B. & Fundulakim I. (2012). Integrating Ontologies and Thesauri to Build RDF Schemas. Translated by Zahra Dehsaraei. Ketabe Mahe Kollyat, 16 (2), 56-71. (In Persian)

Attar, F. (2012). A Study of Quine's Theory of Meaning from the Viewpoint of ‘Indeterminacy of Translation’. Logical Studies, 3 (1), 97-136. (In Persian)

Azad, A. & Sharif, A. (2007). Semantic Web in Relation with Cybernetics. Studies in Education and Psychology, 8 (3), 131-147. (In Persian)

Bell, D. (2010). An Introduction to Cybercultures. Translated by Masoud Kusari & Hossein Hassani. Tehran: Jame-e Shenasan. (In Persian)

Day, R. (2010). The Self-Imposed Limitations of Library and Information Science: Remarks on the Discipline, on the Profession, on the University, and on the state of “information” at Large Today. UCLA Journal of Education and Information Studies, 6 (2), article 6.

Gruber, T. R. (1995). Toward Principles for the Design of Ontologies Used for Knowledge Sharing. Retrieved 14 August, 2012, from: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.89.5775&rep=rep1&type=pdf

Gruber, T. R. (1992). What is an ontology? Retrieved 20 March, 2012, from: http://www-ksl.stanford.edu/kst/what-is-an-ontology.html

Guarino, N. (1998). Formal Ontology in Information Systems. Proceedings of FOIS’98, Trento, Italy, 6-8 June. Amsterdam: IOS Press, pp. 3-15. Retrieved 9 May 2012 from: http://citeseer.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.29.1776&rep=rep1&type=pdf

Guarino, N.; Carrara, M. & Giaretta, P. (1994). Formalizing Ontological Commitments. Proceedings of Annual National Conference of AAAI. Retrieved 5, April, 2013, form: http://www.mit.bme.hu/system/files/oktatas/targyak/7412/Formalizing_Ontological_Commitments.pdf

Hosseini Beheshti, M. (2012). The Conversion of Thesauri to ontology. Ketabe Mahe Kollyat, 16 (2), 26-33. (In Persian)

Jacob, E. K. (2005). Ontologies and Semantic Web. Translated by Fatemeh Sheikh Shoaei. National Studies on Librarianship and Information Organization, 16 (4), 189-194. (In Persian)

Jamali Mahmuei, H. (2003). Semantic Web: An Evolutionary Procedure. Informology, 1 (2), 48-66. (In Persian)

Khansari, M. (2009). Formal Logic (Vol. 1 & 2). Tehran. Agah. (In Persian)

Lauser, B. (2005). From Thesauri to Ontologies: A Short Case Study of Food Safety Eara in How Ontologies are more Powerful Thesauri, from Thesauri to RDFS to OWL. Translated by Narges Ghadimi. National Studies on Librarianship and Information Organization, 16 (4), 145-150. (In Persian)

Meysami, S. (2006). Meaning and Knowledge in Quine’s Philosophy. Tehran: Negahe Moaser. (In Persian)

Meysami, S. (2006). Quine’s Ontological Relativity and Realism in the Framework of Exprimental Science. Philosophy, 34 (1), 143-160. (In Persian)

Nouruzi, M. & Taherian, M. (2012). Basics and Principles of Semantic Web. Tehran: Faras. (In Persian)

Quine, W.V.O. (2012). From Stimulus to Science. Translated by Majid Davodi. Tehran. Hekmat. (In Persian)

Quine, W.V.O. (2006). Ontological Relativity. Translated by Mojtaba Derayati. The Quartely of Mind, 7 (3), 123-142. (In Persian)

Quine, W.V.O. (2002). The Web of Belief. Translated by Amir Divani. Tehran: Soroush; Ketabe Taha. (In Persian)

Sowa, J. F. (1997). Principles of ontology. Retrieved 12 May 2013 from: http://www-ksl.stanford.edu/onto-std/mailarchive/0136.html

Safari, M. (2004). Conceptual Modeling in Formal Knowledge Representation: Undrestanding Artificial Intelligence and Information Systems. Informology, 1 (4), 73-104. (In Persian)

Sanatjoo, A. (2012). Functionality of Ontologies in Information Retrieval Systems. Ketabe Mahe Kollyat, 16 (2), 42-47. (In Persian)

Sanatjoo, A. & Fathian, A. (2011). Studying the Efficiency of Theseuri and Ontology in Knowledge Representation (Design and Development of ASFA). Library and Information Research Journal, 1 (1), 219-240. (In Persian)

Shadgar, B.; Osareh, A. & Haratian Nejadi, A. (2010). Semantic web; Concepts and Techniques. Tehran: Armaghan. (In Persian)

Shaghaghi, M. (2011). Simulation of Signs in Virtual Reality. Sooreh-y-e Andisheh, 62 & 63 (August & September), 113-117. (In Persian)

Sharif, A. (2009). Athomative Engineering of Ontology: Feasibility Study of Semantic Relation Extraction from Persion Texts and determination of Their Presence. Library and Information Science, 12 (2), 243-259. (In Persian)

Wielinga, B. J. et al (2011). From Thesaurus to Ontology. Translated by Mahdi Shaghaghi. Scholarly Communication E-Journal, 22 (3), (In Persian) Retrieved July 13, 2013, from: http://ejournal.irandoc.ac.ir/browse.php?a_code=A-10-1663-1

Wyssusek, Boris (2004). Ontology and Ontologies in Information Systems Analysis and Design: A Critique. Proceedings of the Tenth Americas Conference on Information Systems, New York, August 2004, Retrieved, August 12, 2012, from: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download;jsessionid=BC8AF4B8A311674A4C3F253F42670893?doi=10.1.1.60.7091&rep=rep1&type=pdf

Zuniga, G. L. (2001). Ontology: Its Transformation From Philosophy to Information Systems. Retrieved 13 June, 2012, from: http://pdf.aminer.org/000/212/672/ontology_its_transformation_from_philosophy_to_information_systems.pdf